
Rule · how5
Choose it yourself
You pick the activity or how to do it, with reasons given instead of orders.
| Topic | Evidence | Potential benefit |
|---|---|---|
| Goals | ||
| Motivation |
How sure is this?
- Goals
Choosing it yourself may help you get more done. Studies disagree.
- Well-controlled studies, but only together with other tools.
- One star off: the studies disagree.
Benefit size from A year of choice and enjoyment raised exercise and weight loss in women, against women who took a health course.
- Motivation
Choosing it yourself may help with motivation.
- Well-controlled studies, but only together with other tools.
- One star off: every study behind it has a serious concern.
Benefit size from A year of choice and enjoyment raised exercise and weight loss in women, against women who took a health course.
What 11 studies found
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- No differenceTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedUsed
Paper
- HelpedUsed
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- No differenceUsed
Paper
- HelpedTestedAcross 41 studies, people given a choice were more motivated than people with no choice.
Signs that small negative studies went unpublished
Review
- HelpedTestedAcross 11 studies, people given a choice did better at the task than people with no choice.
Signs that small negative studies went unpublished
Review
- HelpedTestedAcross 7 studies, people given a choice felt more capable at the task than people with no choice.
Signs that small negative studies went unpublished
Review
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedUsed
Paper
- HelpedUsed
Paper
- HelpedUsed
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- MixedTested
Paper
- MixedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- HelpedTested
Paper
- No differenceTested
Paper
- MixedTested
Paper
Often used with it
Action5
Set a specific goal
Choose a concrete goal or target to reach.
Action5
Clarify what matters to you
ACT-style values work and committed action toward them.
Action6
Solve problems step by step
Structured problem solving: define, list options, choose, try, review.
Rule · with whom5
With a coach or therapist
Guided by a coach, therapist or trained helper.