ÜBERMAD

GoalsPaper

A short writing task raised grades for Black students.

HelpedThe short version

Black students who wrote about their top value got better grades in that course.

A girl with braids sits at a classroom desk, drawing small looped curls with a pen on a big sheet of ruled paper.
243
Black and White seventh-graders at one middle school
Randomised
groups picked at random
Recorded
behaviour was recorded
1 tool
tested

The study

  1. Who took part

    243 seventh-graders at one suburban middle school. 119 were Black and 124 were White. Their families were middle class or lower-middle class.

  2. What they did

    Each student did one of two writing tasks in class, taking about 15 minutes. One group wrote why their top value mattered to them; the other wrote why their lowest value might matter to someone else. The first study gave one task, and the replication gave two.

  3. What happened

    Black students in the values group got 0.26 and 0.34 grade points more than the other group. That cut the racial gap by about 40%, and 9 in 100 got a D or below, against 20 in 100. White students showed no change in either study.

What the study found

  1. Helped

    Black students who wrote about their top value got better grades in that course.

    Randomised trial of 243 Black and White seventh-graders at one middle school · vs students who wrote about a least important value · behaviour was recorded

  2. Helped

    Fewer Black students who wrote about their top value got a D or below.

    Randomised trial of 243 Black and White seventh-graders at one middle school · vs students who wrote about a least important value · behaviour was recorded

  3. Helped

    Black students who wrote about their top value also got better grades in other courses.

    Randomised trial of 243 Black and White seventh-graders at one middle school · vs students who wrote about a least important value · behaviour was recorded

How solid is this?

  • Groups picked at random
  • Behaviour was recorded

Source

Reducing the Racial Achievement Gap: A Social-Psychological Intervention (2006)

DOI: 10.1126/science.1128317 (opens in a new tab)

More on goals

See all