ÜBERMAD
Paper

Swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks worked no better than swapping them for water

A woman and a man stand at a counter, each pouring a plain bottle into a glass in step, a capped soda bottle between them.
No difference

Swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks cut sugary drinks no more than swapping them for water.

136
adults who drink a lot of sugary drinks
Randomised
groups picked at random
Self-rated
people rated themselves
1 tool
tested

The study

  1. Who took part

    136 adults who saw themselves as frequent sugary-drink drinkers, out of 184 who started. They were about 31 on average, about half were women, and most lived in the UK or the US.

  2. What they did

    Everyone wrote up to three if-then plans to swap their usual sugary drink for another drink. They kept the plans where they could see them and got a weekly reminder email for two months. One group swapped to water and the other to diet drinks.

  3. What happened

    After two months, both groups drank far fewer sugary drinks: about 4 a week, down from 12. The drop was the same in both groups. With no group that made no plans, we can't tell what caused the drop. The paper's numbers don't always match, and more people were left out of the diet-drink group.

What the study found

  1. No differenceGoals

    Swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks cut sugary drinks no more than swapping them for water.

    Randomised trial of 136 adults who drink a lot of sugary drinks · vs people who swapped to water instead · they rated themselves · ⚠ only counted people who finished; numbers unreliable; uneven outlier exclusions between groups

  2. No differenceHabits

    Sugary drinks felt no less automatic after a swap to diet drinks than after a swap to water.

    Randomised trial of 136 adults who drink a lot of sugary drinks · vs people who swapped to water instead · they rated themselves · ⚠ only counted people who finished; numbers unreliable; uneven outlier exclusions between groups

How solid is this?

  • Groups picked at random
  • People rated themselves
  • Only counted people who finished
  • Numbers unreliable
  • Uneven outlier exclusions between groups

Source

A Habit-Based Randomised Controlled Trial to Reduce Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Consumption: the Impact of the Substituted Beverage on Behaviour and Habit Strength (2020)

DOI: 10.1007/s12529-020-09906-4 (opens in a new tab)

More on goals

See all