ÜBERMAD

GoalsReview

Plans for when and where may help adults be a little more active

HelpedThe short version

Across nine studies, if-then plans and plans for when and where helped adults exercise more than the other group did.

A man in walking shoes presses a weekly plan card onto a cork board beside his back door, calm and planning ahead.
9
studies pooled
789
adults in 26 studies on physical activity
2 tools
tested

The review

  1. Who took part

    Adults with average ages from 18 to 64, in 26 studies: 789 people at the end and 2,749 later on. Eleven studies used students, eight used patients, and seven used the general population.

  2. What they did

    People in one group made plans for when, where and how to act, or if-then plans for what to do about obstacles. Other groups filled in a questionnaire, got usual care or got another treatment. People were checked again one to 46 weeks later, with no contact in between.

  3. What happened

    People were more active than the other groups straight after the plans, and still later on, by a small to medium amount. Most studies only looked at people who finished, and twelve used questions that had not been checked. Extra findings for students, patients and obstacle plans were less certain, and the paper's counts do not quite agree.

What the review found

  1. Helped

    Across nine studies, if-then plans and plans for when and where helped adults exercise more than the other group did.

    Pooled analysis of 9 studies with 789 people · vs people given another treatment, usual care or a questionnaire · ⚠ mixes trials with other kinds of study

  2. Helped

    Across 19 studies, the plans still helped people exercise more, up to 46 weeks after they ended.

    Pooled analysis of 19 studies with 2,749 people · vs people given another treatment, usual care or a questionnaire · ⚠ mixes trials with other kinds of study

How solid is this?

  • Only counted people who finished
  • Many people dropped out
  • Summary claims more than the results show
  • Numbers unreliable
  • Mixes trials with other kinds of study

Source

A meta-analytic review of the effect of implementation intentions on physical activity (2013)

DOI: 10.1080/17437199.2011.560095 (opens in a new tab)

More on goals

See all