ÜBERMAD
Rule · how

Write down when and where

A written action plan with time and place.

A kneeling man in a checked shirt swings a wooden mallet down onto a yellow stake fixed in a block of earth.

Does it work?

It helps a little with habits, and makes little or no difference to goals and motivation.

HabitsHelps a littleWe’re fairly sure

How many studies found it helped

6 of 6 well-run studies

Why we’re fairly sure

Well-run studies, but they only tested it together with other tools.

How big the effect is

In 10 studies, help to plan, track and get reminders made exercise feel more automatic than for the rest.

From the fairest test we have: Effects of habit formation interventions on physical activit

See 9 studies
GoalsLittle or no differenceWe’re fairly sure

How many studies found it helped

5 of 5 well-run studies

Why we’re fairly sure

Several well-run studies, including one that tested it on its own. The studies disagree.

Why so little, if most studies helped

Across 13 studies, workers who took the programme changed their jobs more often than people who got nothing.

From the fairest test we have: Job crafting interventions for employees

See 16 studies
MotivationLittle or no differenceWe’re fairly sure

How many studies found it helped

2 of 3 well-run studies

Why we’re fairly sure

The review’s authors rated their certainty as moderate.

Why so little, if most studies helped

Across 9 studies, workers who took the programme felt more engaged in their work than people who got nothing.

From the fairest test we have: Job crafting interventions for employees

See 7 studies
Time managementToo early to say

How many studies found it helped

1 of 1 well-run study

Why it’s too early

One well-run study, which tested it together with other tools. Every study behind it has a serious weakness.

See 1 study

How sure we are depends on how many well-run studies there are and whether they agree. How we rate

What is this based on?

28 studies. 12 are well run.

12 are reviews that pool many studies. Biggest first.

Well run 12

  1. HelpedEffects of habit formation interventions on physical activit10 studies pooled · 2023

    What they tried

    People got help to build an exercise habit.

    What happened

    In 10 studies, help to plan, track and get reminders made exercise feel more automatic than for the rest.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 10 studies with 2,349 people · vs a mix of other groups · they rated themselves Caveat: whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited

    Read the study
  2. PartlyJob crafting interventions for employees13 studies pooled · 2019

    What they tried

    In the programmes, workers set goals and made plans to change their jobs, sometimes with the company's goals too.

    What happened

    Across 13 studies, workers who took the programme changed their jobs more often than people who got nothing.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 13 studies with 1,080 people · vs people who got nothing · they rated themselves Caveat: whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited; mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  3. HelpedEffectiveness of Interventions and Behaviour Change Techniqu17 studies pooled · 2019

    What they tried

    People got lifestyle programmes, mostly aimed at eating more fruit and vegetables.

    What happened

    Across 17 studies, programmes with goals and plans helped young adults eat more fruit and vegetables than the other groups.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 17 studies · vs a mix of different other groups · they rated themselves Caveat: signs that small negative studies went unpublished; whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited

    Read the study
  4. PartlyWeb-tailored activity and diet programme790 people · 2016

    What they tried

    One group got 8 weekly web sessions.

    What happened

    Plans for when, where and how to move built a stronger habit at 8 weeks, but not at 3 months.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 790 adults in Germany and the Netherlands · vs people who were waiting for the programme · they rated themselves Caveat: many people dropped out; numbers unreliable; summary claims more than the results show

    Read the study
  5. Helped10 Top Tips habit leaflet for weight loss537 people · 2017

    What they tried

    One group had one 30-minute talk with a nurse about a leaflet of 10 everyday eating and activity habits.

    What happened

    With a tip sheet, plans and daily ticks, food and exercise habits felt more automatic than in usual care.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 537 adults with obesity in England · vs usual weight-loss care · they rated themselves

    Read the study
  6. HelpedHabit tools trial497 people · 2026

    What they tried

    Both groups had one 15-minute online session.

    What happened

    People who got a plan, phone reminders and skip days did the exercise more, and it felt more automatic.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 497 US adults with smartphones · vs the same exercise and cue without habit tools · they rated themselves

    Read the study
  7. PartlyMotivational phone call for blood donors484 people · 2017

    What they tried

    About six weeks after giving blood, one group had a 13-minute phone call about their reasons, fears, confidence and values.

    What happened

    A short call about reasons, barriers and plans raised donors' own drive to give blood more than a reminder call.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 484 first-time blood donors in the US · vs a thank-you call with a next-date reminder · behaviour was recorded

    Read the study
  8. HelpedExtended vs brief treatment for marijuana use291 people · 2000

    What they tried

    One group had 14 two-hour sessions over 18 weeks, weekly at first and then every other week.

    What happened

    Group sessions led to fewer days of marijuana use than waiting four months did.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 291 adults seeking treatment for marijuana use · vs people who waited four months for treatment · they rated themselves Caveat: summary claims more than the results show

    Read the study
  9. HelpedPlanning and recycling boxes at work109 people · 2006

    What they tried

    Some groups wrote down, on a computer, when, where and how they would use central boxes for paper and cups.

    What happened

    Writing down when, where and how to recycle cut the paper and cups people put in their bins.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 109 office workers at a Dutch telecom company · vs groups that only had their bins checked · behaviour was recorded Caveat: whole groups were assigned, not people

    Read the study
  10. No changeStepWise web walking programme pilot97 people · 2016

    What they tried

    For 12 weeks, one group got step goals that rose each week and logged their steps on a website.

    What happened

    Step goals with online logs and tips did not make people keener or surer about walking than a step counter.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 97 inactive adults over 25 · vs a step counter, a step target and emails · behaviour was recorded Caveat: only counted people who finished; many people dropped out; numbers unreliable

    Read the study
  11. HelpedHabit-based diet sessions for older dental patients54 people · 2023

    What they tried

    One group had three one-to-one talks of about 30 minutes over 4 weeks.

    What happened

    Planning one new eating habit at a time made healthy food feel more automatic than a leaflet did.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 54 older dental patients in Northern Ireland · vs people who only got a healthy-eating leaflet · they rated themselves Caveat: numbers unreliable; many people dropped out

    Read the study
  12. HelpedExercise self-regulation for adults with diabetes23 people · 2016

    What they tried

    The planning group had four short sessions with a health educator over four weeks.

    What happened

    Adults who planned exercise each week said they used more time management than the other group.

    How it was tested

    Very small randomised trial of 23 overweight adults with type 2 diabetes · vs the same meetings without a plan or log · they rated themselves Caveat: numbers unreliable

    Read the study

Weaker 16

Show weaker studies
  1. PartlyInteractive diabetes self-management16 studies pooled · 2016

    What they tried

    The programmes used goals, feedback, problem-solving and action plans.

    What happened

    Across 16 trials, programmes with goals, feedback and planning lowered blood sugar more than others did.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 16 studies with 3,545 people · vs people who got usual care or other treatment Caveat: the studies disagreed a lot; whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited

    Read the study
  2. HelpedPlanning for physical activity: meta-analysis9 studies pooled · 2013

    What they tried

    People in one group made plans for when, where and how to act, or if-then plans for what to do about obstacles.

    What happened

    Across nine studies, if-then plans and plans for when and where helped adults exercise more than the other group did.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 9 studies with 789 people · vs people given another treatment, usual care or a questionnaire Caveat: mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  3. PartlyImplementation intentions for physical activity11 studies pooled · 2018

    What they tried

    People made plans for when and where to be active, and if-then plans for when things got in the way.

    What happened

    Across 11 studies, plans did not clearly make people more active than the other groups.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 11 studies with 2,247 people · vs people who got videos, leaflets or meetings about being active · they rated themselves

    Read the study
  4. HelpedTechniques to raise activity in obese adults42 studies pooled · 2013

    What they tried

    Programmes used about 10 ways to change behaviour, such as goal setting and tracking progress.

    What happened

    Across 12 comparisons, programmes that had people plan when and where to act tended to give them more confidence.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 12 studies with 1,563 people · vs programmes that did not plan when and where · they rated themselves Caveat: whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited; mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  5. HelpedPsychological help for rheumatoid arthritis5 studies pooled · 2010

    What they tried

    Each study compared psychological help with usual care, a group that waited, or a group that got nothing.

    What happened

    Help that used more goal setting, planning, tracking and feedback eased low mood more than help that used fewer.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 19 studies · vs help with fewer of these parts · they rated themselves Caveat: most studies had serious flaws; whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited

    Read the study
  6. HelpedTechniques for physical activity programmes36 studies pooled · 2011

    What they tried

    Most programmes were about walking or gardening, and 19 were one-to-one while 8 were in groups.

    What happened

    Programmes that had a plan for when and where to be active got people to do more activity.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 4 studies with 541 people · vs the same programmes without a plan Caveat: whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited; mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  7. PartlyPatient activation for kidney disease4 studies pooled · 2023

    What they tried

    All the programmes gave people education, goal setting, action plans and help with solving problems, often with a coach.

    What happened

    Across four studies, programmes that set goals, made plans and solved problems helped adults do more self-care than usual care.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 4 studies with 368 people · vs people who got usual care · they rated themselves · the authors rated their certainty high Caveat: results look too good to be true; the studies disagreed a lot; whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited

    Read the study
  8. No changeTheory of planned behaviour interventions40 studies pooled · 2016

    What they tried

    Each programme used one or more methods, such as giving information, building skills or setting goals.

    What happened

    Across nine studies, detailed planning did not change behaviour more than other groups did.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 9 studies · vs groups that got no help with plans · they rated themselves Caveat: mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  9. Not testedFuture-self imagery audio for students193 people · 2015

    What they tried

    For four weeks, one group listened twice a week to a 9-minute recording.

    What happened

    Students who pictured their future self twice a week put things off no less than those who meditated.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 193 university students in Canada · vs students who listened to a calming meditation · they rated themselves Caveat: student thesis, not checked by other scientists; numbers unreliable

    Read the study
  10. HelpedHabit-formation plus supervised gym programme139 people · 2025

    What they tried

    The programme group had one session on building habits.

    What happened

    Men who planned set exercise times, laid out gym clothes and trained with coaches moved more than men without it.

    How it was tested

    Trial, groups not picked at random of 139 inactive men at a Saudi university · vs men who got no programme · behaviour was recorded Caveat: numbers unreliable

    Read the study
  11. Not testedHabit formation for flossing and vitamin C118 people · 2015

    What they tried

    Households were split by chance to floss before or after brushing, and to a leaflet on looks or on dental health.

    What happened

    Flossing after brushing did not feel more automatic than flossing before it.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 118 adults from around London · vs people who flossed before brushing · they rated themselves Caveat: student thesis, not checked by other scientists; whole groups were assigned, not people; numbers unreliable

    Read the study
  12. No changeTop Tips habit-based weight-loss app pilot81 people · 2019

    What they tried

    Two app groups used an app on their own for 3 months.

    What happened

    Plans, logs and daily reminders in an app did not clearly help people eat well more than waiting.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 81 overweight adults in the UK · vs people who waited for the app · they rated themselves Caveat: many people dropped out; numbers unreliable; only counted people who finished; groups weren't properly compared

    Read the study
  13. Not testedIf-then plans and coupon collection72 people · 2008

    What they tried

    One group planned when, where and how they would collect a coupon.

    What happened

    A specific if-then plan got more people to collect a coupon than a plan about spending it.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 72 undergraduate students in a lab experiment · vs people who planned how to spend the coupon · behaviour was recorded

    Read the study
  14. Not testedHome-visit child-feeding habit goals for parents57 people · 2014

    What they tried

    Parents had four one-hour home visits with a trained researcher, about two weeks apart.

    What happened

    Parents who set one clear food goal at a time said it felt much more automatic within six weeks.

    How it was tested

    Small study of one group of 57 parents of young children in London · no comparison group · they rated themselves Caveat: intervention arm only, no comparison analysed; post-hoc analysis; numbers unreliable

    Read the study
  15. Not testedWalking app with coaching calls after cancer44 people · 2024

    What they tried

    People used a free NHS app that counts 10-minute brisk walks.

    What happened

    After planning 10-minute brisk walks with an app and two coach calls, brisk walking felt more automatic. There was no other group to compare with.

    How it was tested

    Small study of one group of 44 inactive adults after cancer treatment · no comparison group · they rated themselves Caveat: groups weren't properly compared; results not tested statistically

    Read the study
  16. HelpedPhysical activity programmes for inactive adults14 studies pooled · 2018

    What they tried

    Each trial gave people a programme to get them moving more.

    What happened

    Six months or more later, programmes with a plan for when and where, reminders or rising steps got bigger gains.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 0 studies · vs programmes without that part Caveat: most studies had serious flaws; whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited

    Read the study

What is it often used with?

Updated 30 Oct 2026