ÜBERMAD
Action

Reflect on how you performed

Write a structured reflection on your own performance: strengths, obstacles you overcame and what you would do differently.

A young man on a stage edge dots a pen down a sheet ruled into three bands, glancing out at the empty seats.

Does it work?

It may help moderately with goals.

GoalsHelps moderatelyWe’re not very sure

How many studies found it helped

No well-run studies yet

Why we’re not very sure

A review that skipped some quality checks.

How big the effect is

Across 46 samples, looking back at events and getting feedback helped people do better at work.

From the fairest test we have: Debriefs and performance: meta-analysis

See 4 studies
MotivationToo early to say

How many studies found it helped

No well-run studies yet

Why it’s too early

A review that skipped some quality checks. The studies disagree.

What we have so far

After the lessons, students felt more sure their effort would make a difference to their studies.

From the fairest test we have: App diaries and online study training

See 4 studies

How sure we are depends on how many well-run studies there are and whether they agree. How we rate

What is this based on?

7 studies.

6 are reviews that pool many studies. Biggest first.

Weaker 7

  1. HelpedSelf-regulated learning in online courses92 studies pooled · 2023

    What they tried

    Students in online or blended courses were given support to manage their own learning.

    What happened

    Across 92 studies, students in online and blended courses scored better on tests after getting the support.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 92 studies · vs students taught the usual way Caveat: signs that small negative studies went unpublished; whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited; mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  2. HelpedDebriefs and performance: meta-analysis46 studies pooled · 2013

    What they tried

    People looked back at a recent event, using input from someone else or from recorded data, and talked about what to change.

    What happened

    Across 46 samples, looking back at events and getting feedback helped people do better at work.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 46 studies with 2,136 people · vs people who had no review Caveat: whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited; mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  3. HelpedMetacognitive prompts in computer lessons42 studies pooled · 2022

    What they tried

    Students in the prompt groups got prompts while they used learning software, either once or all the way through a session.

    What happened

    Across 42 studies, prompts to plan, check and reflect helped students learn more than getting no prompts did.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 42 studies · vs students who got no prompts Caveat: mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  4. PartlyMetacognition teaching for young children38 studies pooled · 2024

    What they tried

    The programmes taught children to plan before a task, check progress, choose ways of working and think back afterwards.

    What happened

    In 38 studies, a programme that taught children to plan, watch progress and reflect helped their language test scores.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 38 studies · vs usual lessons or similar activities Caveat: the studies disagreed a lot; whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited; mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  5. HelpedSelf-assessment and self-efficacy, meta-analysis12 studies pooled · 2017

    What they tried

    Students judged the quality of their own work, for example by keeping a log, marking their own work or using a checklist.

    What happened

    Students who judged their own work used study strategies a bit more than students who did not.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 12 studies with 369 people · vs students who did not judge their own work · they rated themselves Caveat: whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited; mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  6. HelpedDietary self-efficacy meta-analysis54 studies pooled · 2014

    What they tried

    Each programme was compared with a different programme or with nothing.

    What happened

    Prompting people to review their goals helped them feel more able to eat well.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 9 studies · vs programmes that did not ask for a review · they rated themselves Caveat: most studies had serious flaws; whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited

    Read the study
  7. HelpedApp diaries and online study training73 people · 2020

    What they tried

    Three groups each got something for three weeks.

    What happened

    After the lessons, students felt more sure their effort would make a difference to their studies.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 73 university students in Australia · vs students who got nothing · they rated themselves Caveat: many people dropped out; only counted people who finished; summary claims more than the results show

    Read the study

What is it often used with?

Updated 30 Oct 2026