ÜBERMAD
Action

Give advice to someone facing the same challenge

Write or tell someone else how to overcome the challenge you are working on (saying-is-believing).

A woman writes a note with a fat marker on a big sheet while the man beside her watches with folded hands.

Does it work?

It helps a little with goals.

GoalsHelps a littleWe’re fairly sure

How many studies found it helped

3 of 3 well-run studies

Why we’re fairly sure

Well-run studies, but they only tested it together with other tools.

How big the effect is

Writing why your work matters, and making the case for it, got more kits done than the tutorial-only group.

From the fairest test we have: Nurses' performance with self-persuasion

See 5 studies
FocusToo early to say

How many studies found it helped

1 of 1 well-run study

Why it’s too early

One well-run study, which tested it together with other tools. Every study behind it has a serious weakness.

What we have so far

Their classes also spent more time on schoolwork six weeks later than the other teachers' classes.

From the fairest test we have: Pre-training mindset session for teachers

See 1 study
MotivationToo early to say

How many studies found it helped

1 of 1 well-run study

Why it’s too early

One well-run study, which tested it together with other tools. Every study behind it has a serious weakness.

What we have so far

Teachers who had an hour on how skills grow, letters and a public pledge planned to use new methods more.

From the fairest test we have: Pre-training mindset session for teachers

See 3 studies

How sure we are depends on how many well-run studies there are and whether they agree. How we rate

What is this based on?

5 studies. 3 are well run.

Biggest first.

Well run 3

  1. HelpedNurses' performance with self-persuasion138 people · 2013

    What they tried

    Every group made surgical kits for three hours after a tutorial video.

    What happened

    Writing why your work matters, and making the case for it, got more kits done than the tutorial-only group.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 138 138 nurses at public hospitals in Italy · vs the group that only watched the tutorial · behaviour was recorded

    Read the study
  2. HelpedSocial-belonging message for minority students92 people · 2011

    What they tried

    Students read a report of a survey of older students, who said worries about belonging faded over time.

    What happened

    African American students who got the message had higher GPAs by year three; European American students did not.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 92 first-year college students, African American and European American · vs students who did the same survey on unrelated topics · behaviour was recorded

    Read the study
  3. HelpedPre-training mindset session for teachers43 people · 2022

    What they tried

    Before a two-day course on running a classroom, one group had a one-hour group session.

    What happened

    Teachers who had an hour on how skills grow, letters and a public pledge planned to use new methods more.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 43 primary school teachers in the US · vs a one-hour meeting about schedules · they rated themselves Caveat: summary claims more than the results show

    Read the study

Weaker 2

Show weaker studies
  1. Not testedPen-pal letters on malleable intelligence79 people · 2002

    What they tried

    Students met three times, about 10 days apart, for an hour each.

    What happened

    Black students who wrote that intelligence grows with effort got higher grades than two other groups; White students' gain was less clear.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 79 college students, Black and White · vs the same letters with a different message, or no task · they rated themselves Caveat: only counted people who finished

    Read the study
  2. Not testedBelonging message for Black and White students37 people · 2007

    What they tried

    Students read a survey of older students with made-up numbers and altered quotes.

    What happened

    After reading that others' doubts fade, Black students felt they fit in more, but White students felt less so.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 37 first-year college students, Black and White · vs a message about social and political views · they rated themselves

    Read the study

What is it often used with?

Updated 28 Oct 2026