ÜBERMAD
Action

Read about someone facing the same problem

Read or watch a story whose character struggles with the same problem and learn from how they cope.

A man on a bench lowers his open paperback, looks up with a knowing smile, then raises it to keep reading

Does it work?

It helps moderately with motivation and goals.

MotivationHelps moderatelyWe’re very sure

How many studies found it helped

2 of 2 well-run studies

Why we’re very sure

Several well-run studies, including one that tested it on its own.

How big the effect is

After reading that others' doubts fade, Black students felt they fit in more, but White students felt less so.

From the fairest test we have: Belonging message for Black and White students

See 3 studies
GoalsHelps moderatelyWe’re fairly sure

How many studies found it helped

3 of 4 well-run studies

Why we’re fairly sure

Several well-run studies, including one that tested it on its own. The studies disagree.

How big the effect is

Over the next week, Black students said they studied and emailed teachers more after reading that others' doubts fade.

From the fairest test we have: Belonging message for Black and White students

See 4 studies

How sure we are depends on how many well-run studies there are and whether they agree. How we rate

What is this based on?

7 studies. 5 are well run.

1 is a review that pools many studies. Biggest first.

Well run 5

  1. HelpedRelevance lessons for maths value1,916 people · 2015

    What they tried

    Each class had a 90-minute lesson on why maths matters, then a personal task.

    What happened

    Students who read quotes rated maths as more useful than the waiting group, at six weeks and five months.

    How it was tested

    Large randomised trial of 1,916 ninth-grade students in Germany · vs students still waiting for their lesson · they rated themselves Caveat: whole groups were assigned, not people; summary claims more than the results show

    Read the study
  2. No changeGrowth mindset of mental health for employees252 people · 2026

    What they tried

    Each group had one online session of about 10 minutes.

    What happened

    Reading and writing about how mental health gets better did not clearly raise use of self-help tools in the app.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 252 employees offered a mental health app · vs the same reading and writing about work tools · behaviour was recorded Caveat: summary claims more than the results show; numbers unreliable

    Read the study
  3. HelpedWise feedback for African American students164 people · 2014

    What they tried

    In two studies, a teacher's essay feedback came with a note saying the teacher had high standards.

    What happened

    Over a semester, Black students taught that criticism shows high standards got better grades.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 164 US school students, Black and White · vs students who got placebo stories or puzzles · behaviour was recorded Caveat: only counted people who finished

    Read the study
  4. HelpedSocial-belonging message for minority students92 people · 2011

    What they tried

    Students read a report of a survey of older students, who said worries about belonging faded over time.

    What happened

    African American students who got the message had higher GPAs by year three; European American students did not.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 92 first-year college students, African American and European American · vs students who did the same survey on unrelated topics · behaviour was recorded

    Read the study
  5. HelpedBelonging message for Black and White students37 people · 2007

    What they tried

    Students read a survey of older students with made-up numbers and altered quotes.

    What happened

    After reading that others' doubts fade, Black students felt they fit in more, but White students felt less so.

    How it was tested

    Small randomised trial of 37 first-year college students, Black and White · vs a message about social and political views · they rated themselves

    Read the study

Weaker 2

Show weaker studies
  1. HelpedSelf-efficacy techniques for physical activity27 studies pooled · 2010

    What they tried

    Each study tried to build belief that people could be more active, mostly through everyday activity such as walking.

    What happened

    Across nine tests, those who saw similar people succeed felt surer than the other groups.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 9 studies with 2,151 people · vs people in the other groups · they rated themselves Caveat: whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited; mixes trials with other kinds of study

    Read the study
  2. Not testedGroup bibliotherapy for grade 8 procrastinators7 people · 2020

    What they tried

    The students met as a group with a counsellor four times to talk about books.

    What happened

    After four group talks about book characters, students said they put off schoolwork less.

    How it was tested

    Very small study of one group of 7 grade 8 students in Indonesia · no comparison group · they rated themselves Caveat: summary claims more than the results show

    Read the study

What is it often used with?

Updated 30 Oct 2026