ÜBERMAD

MotivationPaper

Group sessions on personal goals gave people their own reasons to manage diabetes

HelpedThe short version

Group sessions on personal goals gave people more of their own reasons to care for their diabetes than usual care.

A woman on a bench winds yellow yarn into a ball while a smiling man beside her holds the loop steady.
178
adults with poorly controlled type 1 diabetes
Randomised
groups picked at random
Self-rated
people rated themselves
2 tools
tested

The study

  1. Who took part

    178 adults with type 1 diabetes whose blood sugar was poorly controlled, at a university hospital in western Norway. They were about 37 on average; 90 were put in the groups and 88 kept their usual care.

  2. What they did

    One group had seven 2-hour group sessions over 14 weeks. Before and between sessions, they filled in worksheets about daily problems with diabetes. Trained nurses helped each person set their own goals instead of giving orders. The other group kept their usual hospital visits and advice.

  3. What happened

    About 9 months later, people in the groups had more of their own reasons to manage diabetes than the usual-care group. They did not feel more able to manage it, and their blood sugar did not differ. 42 of the 90 people in the groups dropped out. Only people who stayed were counted, and some of the paper's numbers don't add up.

What the study found

  1. Helped

    Group sessions on personal goals gave people more of their own reasons to care for their diabetes than usual care.

    Randomised trial of 178 adults with poorly controlled type 1 diabetes · vs people who kept their usual hospital care · they rated themselves · ⚠ many people dropped out; only counted people who finished; numbers unreliable

  2. No difference

    The same group sessions did not make people feel more able to manage their diabetes than usual care.

    Randomised trial of 178 adults with poorly controlled type 1 diabetes · vs people who kept their usual hospital care · they rated themselves · ⚠ many people dropped out; only counted people who finished; numbers unreliable

How solid is this?

  • Groups picked at random
  • People rated themselves
  • Many people dropped out
  • Only counted people who finished
  • Numbers unreliable

Source

The effect of guided self-determination on self-management in persons with type 1 diabetes mellitus and HbA1c ≥64 mmol/mol: a group-based randomised controlled trial (2017)

DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-013295 (opens in a new tab)

More on motivation

See all