ÜBERMAD
Rule · with whom

Do it with a partner or team

Working or practising together with someone.

A woman on a mat folds forward over her legs while her friend kneels behind her with hands on her back, then sits her up.

Does it work?

It’s too early to say.

ProcrastinationToo early to say

How many studies found it helped

1 of 1 well-run study

Why it’s too early

One well-run study, which tested it together with other tools. Every study behind it has a serious weakness.

See 2 studies
GoalsToo early to say

How many studies found it helped

1 of 1 well-run study

Why it’s too early

A review that skipped some quality checks. The studies disagree.

What we have so far

Workers paid on their pair's shared work did about 21 percent more tasks in all than those paid alone.

From the fairest test we have: Team pay versus solo pay online

See 4 studies

How sure we are depends on how many well-run studies there are and whether they agree. How we rate

What is this based on?

5 studies. 2 are well run.

1 is a review that pools many studies. Biggest first.

Well run 2

  1. PartlyTeam pay versus solo pay online597 people · 2025

    What they tried

    Over three days, people typed short strings of letters for up to 45 minutes in total, spread however they liked.

    What happened

    Workers paid on their pair's shared work did more tasks on day one than workers paid for their own tasks.

    How it was tested

    Randomised trial of 597 online workers in the US · vs workers paid only for their own tasks · behaviour was recorded Caveat: summary claims more than the results show

    Read the study
  2. HelpedExercise self-regulation for adults with diabetes23 people · 2016

    What they tried

    The planning group had four short sessions with a health educator over four weeks.

    What happened

    The planning group also said it used five other skills more, such as tracking progress and setting goals.

    How it was tested

    Very small randomised trial of 23 overweight adults with type 2 diabetes · vs the same meetings without a plan or log · they rated themselves Caveat: numbers unreliable

    Read the study

Weaker 3

Show weaker studies
  1. HelpedBehaviour change techniques for physical activity224 studies pooled · 2018

    What they tried

    Each programme was checked for whether its authors named a theory, and for which of 16 groups of methods it used.

    What happened

    Across 122 programmes, those that added social support got people more active than the other group.

    How it was tested

    Pooled analysis of 122 studies · vs people who got no programme Caveat: whole programmes were tested, so no single part can be credited

    Read the study
  2. PartlyPeer groups in a flipped statistics course268 people · 2024

    What they tried

    All courses had the same online lessons on six topics.

    What happened

    Students in groups of three uploaded tasks about on time, while students who worked alone were about a week late.

    How it was tested

    Trial, groups not picked at random of 268 social work students in Berlin math courses · vs the same course with tasks done alone · behaviour was recorded Caveat: whole groups were assigned, not people; summary claims more than the results show; possible teacher effect

    Read the study
  3. HelpedThink-Pair-Share vs brainstorming in English classes200 people · 2023

    What they tried

    In one group's English lessons, students first thought about a question alone.

    What happened

    Students who thought alone, then talked with a partner, scored a bit higher on English tests.

    How it was tested

    Trial of 200 high school students learning English · vs students who came up with ideas in groups · they rated themselves Caveat: summary claims more than the results show

    Read the study

What is it often used with?

Updated 30 Oct 2026